Blog

Discover the challenges behind rental property ownership. Learn why many landlords burn out and how smart management keeps investments profitable.

Finding reliable tenants in Kansas City’s evolving rental market takes more than a quick background check. Local regulations, including Ordinance 231019, now limit how landlords can use credit, income, and criminal history in screening decisions. Effective tenant screening protects your investment, reduces turnover, and ensures steady rental income while staying compliant with Kansas City’s fair housing standards. When you approach screening with a clear process, you can identify qualified applicants who respect your property and pay on time. At Raven Property Management KC, we understand how to balance thorough vetting with compliance, helping property owners make informed choices that support long-term success. A well-structured system not only saves time but also builds stronger landlord-tenant relationships. Key Takeaways Strong tenant screening safeguards property value and rental income. Compliance with Kansas City’s housing laws reduces legal and financial risk. A consistent, transparent process leads to better tenant relationships. Essential Steps in Tenant Screening for Kansas City Property Owners Effective tenant screening protects rental property owners from financial loss and legal issues. It relies on consistent standards, accurate data, and compliance with Kansas City’s fair housing regulations, including Ordinance 231019, which prohibits discrimination based on source of income, credit score, or criminal history. Establishing Clear Rental Criteria Define objective and measurable rental criteria before advertising a property. Consistent standards help landlords make fair decisions and reduce the risk of legal disputes. Criteria may include minimum income requirements , employment verification , and rental history standards . Document these requirements in writing and apply them equally to every applicant. Avoid using factors restricted under Kansas City’s Ordinance 231019. This includes rejecting applicants solely for criminal history or credit score. Use a checklist to ensure consistency: Monthly income at least 2.5–3 times rent Stable employment or verified income source Positive landlord references No recent evictions or lease violations Clear criteria improve transparency and attract qualified tenants who meet expectations upfront. Conducting Comprehensive Background Checks A thorough background check helps landlords verify identity and assess potential risk. Many new property owners wonder how to do background check for renters in a way that balances thoroughness with compliance. This process typically includes criminal, eviction, and employment history searches. In Kansas City, landlords must ensure screening practices comply with local and federal fair housing laws. Use a reputable screening service that provides FCRA-compliant reports. Review results carefully and evaluate context rather than relying on blanket exclusions. For example, consider the nature and date of any criminal record, as required by Ordinance 231019. Evaluating Credit Reports and Financial Stability A credit report provides insight into an applicant’s financial habits and ability to pay rent on time. The most effective tenant screening approach often combines a credit and background check for renters , giving landlords a clear view of both financial reliability and rental history. Review payment history, outstanding debts, and credit utilization. A pattern of late payments or excessive debt may indicate financial instability. Instead of focusing on credit score alone, look at the full credit profile. Ordinance 231019 discourages rejecting applicants based solely on credit score. Verify whether the applicant meets income and payment obligations despite a lower score. Verifying Landlord References and Rental History Contacting previous landlords offers valuable insight into an applicant’s reliability. Ask direct questions about rent payment history, property care, and lease compliance. Confirm the dates of tenancy and whether the tenant received any notices for late rent or property damage. Be cautious of falsified references. Verify contact information using public records or property databases. Cross-check details with the rental application for consistency. To stay organized during the tenant screening process, it’s helpful to keep a simple reference log that tracks responses from previous landlords. This log should include the landlord’s name, the property address, details about the applicant’s payment record, any history of lease violations, and whether the landlord would recommend renting to the tenant again. For example, a positive reference might note that the tenant at 123 Main Street consistently paid rent on time, had no violations, and would be welcomed back as a renter. Consistently verifying landlord references and documenting rental history in this way helps property owners identify responsible tenants and reduce turnover risk